Donald Trump’s reposting of an article by Tim Sheehy, Republican senator from Montana, published in The Wall Street Journal under the headline “If You Think War Is Unpopular, Wait Until You See Defeat,” cannot be dismissed as merely a media recommendation or a personal interest in a political commentary. The move comes at a time when the author attributes part of the Republicans’ electoral setback to the war with Iran, while simultaneously arguing that the confrontation must continue. The repost should therefore be viewed in the context of Washington’s efforts to manage the political fallout from the war and reconstruct the US administration’s narrative.
By highlighting the article, Trump is effectively seeking to change the terms of the debate. Rather than answering questions about the costs of the war, its military achievements, its economic consequences, or the reasons for prolonging the conflict, he is trying to convince public opinion that the cost of an American defeat would be greater than the cost of continuing the war. This conceptual shift is an attempt to portray a controversial policy choice as an unavoidable necessity. Under this framing, opponents of the war are no longer critics of a costly policy but are instead portrayed as people willing to accept defeat.
The message is primarily aimed at a domestic audience. Trump seeks to contain mounting pressure from public opposition, political criticism and electoral costs by emphasizing the danger of defeat and building a narrative in support of continuing the policy of confrontation. At another level, the repost also sends a message to Washington’s regional allies, signaling that the costs of war and domestic political pressure do not necessarily mean that US policy will change anytime soon.
Iran: An Actor Beyond the Calculations of War Hawks
One of the article’s fundamental weaknesses is its reduction of Iran to a political structure whose fate can supposedly be determined through military pressure and the creation of favorable external conditions. Drawing on the experience of the Korean War and Harry Truman’s decision-making, the author argues that, as in that historical case, the political costs of the war against Iran will eventually be justified. However, this comparison overlooks fundamental differences between the two conflicts.
Iran is neither North Korea nor South Korea, nor is it a country with geopolitical characteristics comparable to those of the Korean Peninsula. Its geographical position, population, strategic depth, defense capabilities, political structure, and role in the energy and security equations of West Asia create a complex set of variables that make any military calculation involving the country particularly challenging. Moreover, Iran has a long history of confronting foreign pressure, sanctions, threats and an imposed war. This experience has played a significant role in shaping its defense and security doctrine.
From this perspective, one of the article’s most significant strategic miscalculations is equating potential domestic dissatisfaction with a society’s willingness to accept foreign military intervention. The existence of economic, social or political grievances in any society does not, in itself, mean that its people are prepared to surrender their right to determine their own future to foreign powers. Defending independence and territorial integrity can also become a significant factor in social and political behavior, regardless of domestic disagreements.
Psychological Warfare: From Intimidating Tehran to Pressuring Allies
Another important element of Trump’s message is the emphasis on the claim that, if the war ends, Iran will have an opportunity to rebuild its economy, expand its missile and drone capabilities, and restore its regional ties. This section of the article is aimed not only at the American public but also directly at Tehran’s calculations and those of neighboring countries.
The communication strategy behind this narrative can be examined on three levels. First, it seeks to create the impression that any agreement or cessation of hostilities would amount to strengthening Iran and forcing the United States to retreat. Second, it aims to heighten Washington’s allies’ concerns about the potential consequences of ending the war without achieving its declared objectives. Third, it sends a message to Iran that military and economic pressure will continue until Tehran accepts Washington’s demands.
However, this narrative overlooks an important reality: deterrence cannot be measured solely by the number of weapons a country possesses or the amount of damage inflicted on its adversary. The ability to retaliate, geographical position, capacity to withstand pressure, cohesion of the defense structure, and ability to impose costs on an aggressor are also essential components of national power. Reducing the equation involving Iran to the rebuilding of its missile and drone arsenals therefore ignores a significant part of the country’s strategic reality.
In the same context, the claim that the war against Iran is about protecting Western civilization and the security of American families represents an attempt to securitize and frame a political and military conflict as a civilizational struggle. Such framing may marginalize opposition to the war, but it does not answer the central question: Does continuing the war actually enhance US security, or does it create new costs and broader risks?
Iran’s Strategic Equation: Independence, Deterrence and Diplomacy
In contrast to this narrative, Iran’s strategic equation can be examined through three fundamental components: preserving independent decision-making, maintaining deterrent capabilities, and pursuing diplomacy based on national interests and rights. These three components are neither mutually exclusive nor can any one of them replace the others.
Iran’s historical experience has shown that foreign pressure alone cannot steer domestic developments in accordance with the wishes of interventionist powers. The Islamic Republic, within the framework of its political and defense structures, also emphasizes its right to defend national sovereignty, territorial integrity and the country’s strategic interests. From this perspective, any lasting agreement will only be possible if it is based on mutual respect, credible guarantees, and an end to threats and coercion.
At the same time, Trump’s reposting of the article should not, by itself, be interpreted as a definitive decision to escalate military operations. More than anything, the move constitutes a political and media message that can serve several purposes simultaneously: managing American public opinion, maintaining cohesion among pro-war political forces, putting pressure on allies, and strengthening Washington’s bargaining position. Distinguishing between psychological operations, political threats and actual operational decisions is essential to accurately assessing developments.
The decisive point is that, by presenting a false choice between “continuing the war or accepting defeat,” Washington is seeking to narrow the range of political options. Yet, from the perspective of Iran’s national interests, neither accepting foreign dictates nor ignoring the need for the prudent management of the crisis offers a viable solution. National power becomes meaningful when defense capabilities, domestic cohesion, economic capacity and active diplomacy operate together.
Ultimately, the main issue for Iran is neither proving Trump’s narrative right nor becoming trapped in Washington’s propaganda framework. It is preserving the initiative in determining its own security and political equations. The United States may use the reposting of hawkish articles to magnify the cost of defeat in the eyes of its domestic audience, but it cannot use narrative engineering to override the will of a nation or decide Iran’s political and security future on its behalf. The distinction between military power and the ability to determine one’s own destiny is precisely what has been overlooked in Washington’s hawkish calculations.