Two More Difficult Years Ahead

By Kourosh Ahmadi

Two More Difficult Years Ahead
0 minute

NOURNEWS – On November 12, Donald Trump was asked by journalist Hugh Hewitt: “If, when your term ends, the Iranian regime is still in power, will that be a failure for you?”

He replied: “Yes. That would be a failure. I would say that would be a failure.”

The categorical nature of this statement, and the emphasis Trump placed on it, may well reflect his genuine mindset and could go down in history. Iran has been one of his main preoccupations throughout his first four years in office and the first two years of his second term. By entering a war that he had promised his political base he would avoid, he incurred considerable political damage, deepened divisions within that base and suffered an overwhelming and highly unusual defeat in the midterm elections. This aggression against Iran also played a part in preventing him from delivering economic gains, the principal yardstick by which US presidents are judged.

Against this backdrop, Trump is approaching the final two years of his presidency, a period traditionally dominated by concerns over his legacy. The Democrats' overwhelming majority in Congress has opened up two difficult years for him, particularly as Congress is set to examine corruption allegations involving Trump and his family, as well as the damage he has inflicted on American democracy and institutions. With inflation at 4.1% and unemployment at 4.2% in October, the prospects for economic achievements are also far from clear.

Trump, therefore, is likely to follow the pattern of most of his predecessors and be compelled to focus on foreign policy during the remaining two years of his term. Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama all did so. After Democrats regained control of both chambers of Congress in 1986, following eight years, Reagan devoted much of his time to foreign policy issues, including arms control, the conflict in the Persian Gulf and the aftermath of the Iran-Contra scandal. The final two years of the presidencies of George H.W. Bush and Clinton were, respectively, dominated by the Iraq war and the end of the Cold War, and by Middle East peace negotiations. After the Republicans' defeat in the 2006 midterm elections, George W. Bush was largely preoccupied with Iraq and the increase in US military presence there. In his final two years, Obama was primarily occupied with the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), the Crimean War, the Trans-Pacific trade agreement and the opening to Cuba.

Given the obstacles he faces in domestic policy because of Congress, Trump is also likely to seek achievements in foreign policy during his remaining two years, with Iran expected to be his principal focus in this area. In the wake of his overwhelming defeat in Congress and opposition from Democrats and public opinion to a resumption of the war, he is likely, for the time being, to lean more toward the position of the economic-pressure faction within his administration.

The key question now is whether he will stick to this course or whether a return to war remains possible. Having failed to achieve his objectives in the 40-day war, Trump should by now have come to understand that regime change cannot be achieved through air-based, stand-off warfare. He should therefore have no intention of repeating a failed experience, particularly given that the Eizenkot faction in Israel holds a similar view.

It is also possible, of course, that the two countries may seek to reach an understanding without a formal agreement. Nevertheless, a return to war cannot be ruled out. If Netanyahu's faction remains in power and manages to manufacture a pretext, whether over the nuclear issue, an assassination or something else, the possibility of another large-scale war must not be overlooked. In that scenario, an Israeli attack with US authorization, while the US assumes a defensive role, could also be considered.

If war is unlikely, however, an important question will be how Iran responds to a scenario involving a naval blockade and pressure on neighboring countries to close their land borders with Iran. If Iran decides that enduring such a scenario for two years is untenable and puts military action on the agenda, the situation will change completely.

Given the circumstances outlined above, the author believes that conditions for the emergence of a serious and effective diplomatic process are more favorable now than at any other time. First, the US failure to achieve its objectives through war has demonstrated that Washington will get nowhere by pursuing a military approach.

Second, Trump's overwhelming election defeat showed that he lacks the necessary legitimacy, both in Congress and in public opinion, to launch another war, although this factor is not necessarily decisive. Third, a naval blockade, if it is to produce any results at all, would take a very long time, something incompatible with Trump's temperament.

Under these circumstances, the conditions for advancing successful negotiations should be more favorable than ever. Clearly, this would require flexibility on both sides. Iran's seven-day or two-day proposal, which in a sense seeks to revive the Islamabad memorandum of understanding, has so far failed to make progress because it has not offered anything in return. On the other hand, it is unlikely that Trump, following his election defeat, would be willing to accept another outright failure.

If the opportunity created by the three factors outlined above is not seized, we will face two even more difficult years.

This article was first published in Persian in Shargh newspaper.

 

Source: Nournews
Related News
Send Comment