Asghar Zarei in an Interview with Nournews

Iraq's Government at a Crossroads: Rely on National Capabilities or Accept the US Prescription?

NOURNEWS – The Iraqi government's disagreements with some Shiite political factions and Resistance groups are among the country's most significant political and security challenges in 2026. The central issues in this dispute are control of weapons, the scope of government authority, and the position of Resistance groups within Iraq's political and security structures. The future of this dispute depends on the government's ability to strike a balance between national sovereignty, the demands of Shiite political factions, and the role of Resistance groups. Asghar Zarei, a Middle East affairs expert, discussed the ongoing disagreements in Iraq in an interview with Nournews.

Iraq's Government at a Crossroads: Rely on National Capabilities or Accept the US Prescription?
0 minute

The Iraqi government's disagreements with some Shiite political factions and Resistance groups are among the country's most significant political and security challenges in 2026. The central issues in this dispute are control of weapons, the scope of government authority, and the position of Resistance groups within Iraq's political and security structures.

Iraqi Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi has sought in recent months to implement a policy of placing weapons under state control and bringing armed groups operating outside the government's direct command under the authority of the official armed forces. This approach has faced opposition from some Resistance groups, particularly Kataib Hezbollah and Harakat al-Nujaba. These groups argue that the presence of foreign forces and regional security threats continue to justify maintaining the Resistance's defensive capabilities. The government, meanwhile, maintains that decisions on war and peace must rest with the country's official institutions.

This disagreement is not merely a military issue; it also has political and economic roots. Some Shiite groups fear that restricting the Resistance's military power would diminish their political influence and weaken their position in Iraq's domestic political dynamics. Meanwhile, the Iraqi government faces pressure from the US and concerns over escalating regional tensions, and is seeking to maintain balanced relations with foreign actors.

It can be said that the future of this dispute depends on the government's ability to strike a balance between national sovereignty, the demands of Shiite political factions, and the role of Resistance groups. Any hasty confrontation could deepen divisions within Iraq's Shiite camp. Conversely, reaching a political and legal agreement could help preserve stability in Iraq and prevent political disagreements from turning into a security crisis.

Asghar Zarei, a Middle East affairs expert, discussed the ongoing disagreements in Iraq in an interview with Nournews.

 

What is the main root of the Iraqi prime minister's disagreement with Resistance groups, and when did it become more serious?

To examine this issue, we need to consider the political and security developments in Iraq over recent years. Following the fall of Saddam Hussein's regime, and particularly during the fight against ISIS, Iraqi Resistance groups became major security and political actors in the country. Alongside Iraq's official forces, these groups played an effective role in confronting terrorist threats and gradually developed considerable operational, organizational and military capabilities.

Over the past several years, successive Iraqi governments have sought to organize these forces within the country's official defense structure, particularly the Popular Mobilization Forces (PMF). However, the issues of command, operational independence and the political position of Resistance groups have remained contentious.

Under the current government, the issue has entered a more sensitive phase as a result of external pressure, particularly US policies. It appears that Washington wants the Iraqi government to exercise greater control over these groups' military activities and prevent the emergence of any independent military capability that could affect US and allied interests in the region.

 

How has the Iraqi prime minister's visit to the US affected the escalation of disagreements with Resistance groups?

The Iraqi prime minister's visit to the US should be examined within the framework of the complex relations between Baghdad and Washington. Iraq remains economically and financially connected to the international financial system, particularly the US. Oil revenues, access to foreign currency reserves, banking transactions and economic cooperation are among the instruments that can play a decisive role in relations between the two countries.

Naturally, the US has the capacity to use these instruments to influence the Iraqi government's decisions. Although it is impossible to make definitive statements about confidential agreements between the two sides without credible evidence, it is possible that controlling armed groups and restricting Resistance activities were among the important topics discussed during their talks.

In my view, Washington is seeking to use Iraq's economic and financial dependencies to gradually alter the balance of power within the country, in a way that would lead the Baghdad government to adopt policies on Resistance groups more closely aligned with US demands.

 

Why is the US so strongly emphasizing restrictions on Resistance groups in Iraq?

Iraq occupies an extremely sensitive geopolitical position. It shares a border with the Islamic Republic of Iran on one side and is connected to Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria and the Persian Gulf region on the other. Iraq's geographical proximity to the occupied territories and the region's communication and transit routes also adds to its security significance.

From the US perspective, the presence of powerful Resistance groups in Iraq could affect Washington's military and security calculations and those of its allies. Particularly amid rising regional tensions and the active presence of Resistance fronts in Lebanon, Yemen and other parts of the region, the operational capabilities of Iraqi groups are of particular importance to the US.

For this reason, one of the US's apparent strategic objectives is to restrict these groups' independent military capabilities and ensure the security of its bases and interests in Iraq and the region.

 

Is the US seeking to implement a model similar to Lebanon for Iraqi Resistance groups?

There appear to be similarities between US policy toward Hezbollah in Lebanon and its approach to Resistance groups in Iraq. In Lebanon, Washington has sought through political, economic and security pressure to make Hezbollah's disarmament a central issue in the country's domestic political dynamics. There are now concerns that the US may seek to use the Iraqi central government's capabilities to exert similar pressure on Resistance groups in Iraq.

However, Iraq's circumstances differ from those of Lebanon. Iraqi Resistance groups have different social and political standing and organizational structures, and some of their forces operate within the Popular Mobilization Forces and the country's official security framework. Consequently, any attempt to eliminate or weaken these groups would face greater complexities.

 

Could the US pressure Iraqi army into a military confrontation with Resistance groups?

This is one of the serious concerns under the current circumstances. If political disagreements are not managed rationally and the government seeks to resolve the weapons issue through a confrontational approach, the risk of escalating security tensions could increase.

It should be noted, however, that the Iraqi army and Resistance forces have cooperated extensively in the fight against ISIS in recent years, and a significant part of the country's defence capabilities was developed through this cooperation. Turning these forces against one another could therefore inflict irreparable damage on Iraq's national security.

At the same time, the possibility of US security pressure and even military attacks on the positions of some Resistance groups cannot be entirely ruled out. Such a scenario could prompt a response from Resistance groups and plunge Iraq into a complex security crisis.

 

How important is the silence or position of Iraq's highest religious authority in these disagreements?

The highest Shiite religious authority in Najaf has always been one of the most influential factors in Iraq's political and social stability. Ayatollah Sistani has demonstrated at various points that preserving Iraq's independence, preventing foreign interference and safeguarding national unity are fundamental priorities for him.

Under these circumstances, a distinction must be made between supporting the government's legal authority and supporting policies driven by external pressure. Naturally, none of Iraq's political or religious factions wants internal disagreements to become a tool for advancing US objectives. The religious authority's refusal to endorse a confrontational approach could carry an important political message for the Baghdad government, particularly if such an approach leads to deeper divisions among Shiite forces.

 

What message do the visits by Iranian commanders to Baghdad and their consultations with Resistance groups convey?

Given its political, security and historical ties with Iraq, Iran naturally follows developments in the country closely. From this perspective, consultations between Iranian officials, the Iraqi government and Resistance groups can be viewed as efforts to prevent further disagreements and manage existing tensions. Tehran, on the one hand, emphasizes the need to maintain friendly relations with Iraq's central government and, on the other, regards Resistance groups as an important part of the region's political and security dynamics.

Accordingly, one of the key objectives of diplomatic consultations could be to establish an understanding between the Baghdad government and Resistance groups, one that preserves Iraq's sovereignty while preventing internal disagreements from turning into military confrontation. However, any reports about the details of meetings and agreements must be assessed on the basis of official information and credible sources.

 

How can these disagreements be managed, and what scenarios lie ahead for Iraq?

In my view, the future of this issue depends on how the Iraqi government deals with Resistance groups and the extent to which Baghdad's decisions are influenced by external pressure. The primary solution is political dialogue and reaching a national agreement. The Iraqi government must be able to preserve its legal authority while also recognizing the position of Resistance groups and their role in the country's national security. In turn, Resistance groups should prioritize political and legal solutions within the framework of Iraq's national interests and the need to preserve the country's stability.

If the Iraqi government seeks to resolve this issue under US pressure and without a domestic agreement, the likelihood of escalating disagreements and even internal conflict will increase.

On the other hand, if Washington believes it can achieve in Iraq the same outcome as the model it has pursued in Lebanon by using economic instruments and political pressure, it may face serious resistance from Iraqi political and social factions.

What we are witnessing in Iraq today is not merely a disagreement between the prime minister and several armed groups. The fundamental issue is a contest over the future of the country's power structure, Iraq's independence in political and security decision-making, and its position in regional dynamics.

In conclusion, Iraq must not become a battleground for settling the scores of foreign powers. Any agreement on the future of Resistance groups must be reached within the framework of national dialogue, the constitution and the interests of the Iraqi people. Otherwise, there is a risk that political disagreements will turn into a security crisis and a deep division within Iraqi society.

 

Source: Nournews
Related News
  • NOURNEWS _ The Iraq War was long regarded as one of the most unpopular wars in US history. However, new polling data show that net support for the US war against Iran has fallen to minus 32 percentage points, below the lowest levels recorded for previous American wars.

  • NOURNEWS – Ali Bagheri Kani, Deputy for Foreign Policy and International Security at the Secretariat of the Supreme National Security Council, said the four-way meeting in Tehran demonstrated a shift in regional countries’ approach to security, emphasizing that Iran’s resistance and indigenous defense capabilities had thwarted the United States and the Zionist regime. He said the developments had underscored the need for regional cooperation and a move away from unilateral reliance on foreign powers.

  • Iraqi Airways has resumed commercial flights between the holy city of Najaf and Iranian airports after Baghdad held direct talks with Washington to secure exemptions for certain aviation facilities from US sanctions.

Send Comment